Supreme Court Takes the Catholic Preschool Case Everyone Saw Coming
St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy asks whether Colorado can bar a parish preschool from universal preschool funding because it will not affirm the state's views on sexuality and family.

The Supreme Court just agreed to answer the question that has been hanging over every religious school in America. Can the government invite everyone to the funding table and then remove the chairs from under believers?
On April 20, the justices granted review in St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy. The case comes out of Littleton, Colorado, where a parish preschool wants to participate in the state's universal preschool program. Colorado pays for preschool for every family, at religious and secular providers alike. But the state excluded St. Mary because the school will not agree to nondiscrimination conditions requiring it to admit all children, including children from families whose structure conflicts with Catholic teaching on marriage and sexuality.
The Tenth Circuit sided with Colorado, finding the conditions were neutral and generally applied to every preschool regardless of religion. The parish argues that is a fig leaf, and that conditioning a public benefit on a religious school surrendering its religious character is exactly the discrimination the First Amendment forbids.
If this sounds familiar, it should. In Trinity Lutheran, Espinoza, and Carson v. Makin, the Court built a straight line of precedent holding that once a state creates a public benefit, it cannot exclude institutions simply for being religious. Colorado's answer is that St. Mary is not being excluded for being religious but for refusing an admissions rule that binds everyone.
That distinction is the whole ballgame. Religious schools do not check their doctrine at the schoolhouse door, and a rule that requires a Catholic school to operate contrary to Catholic teaching as the price of equal treatment is not neutral in any sense a parent would recognize. The Trump administration's solicitor general has backed the preschools, and the case will likely be argued next term.
Be fair to the other side of the argument. Colorado says taxpayer funded programs can insist that every participating provider serve every family, and that no child should be turned away from a subsidized seat because of who her parents are. That concern is not imaginary, and the justices will have to grapple with it.
But notice what the state's position means in practice. It would let any legislature zero out religious education from public programs by writing conditions that only secular providers can meet. That is not pluralism. That is a workaround.
Universal programs keep expanding, from preschool to school choice, and this decision will set the rules of the road for all of them. A country that actually believes in pluralism can fund Catholic preschools, secular preschools, and everything in between, and let parents choose. We will find out by summer 2027 whether the Constitution still reads that way.
Sources
Questions readers ask
What is Media Mogul News?
Media Mogul News is an independent, reader-supported news site led by Chief Editor Nate Jurewicz. We cover the stories corporate media skips: political corruption, Big Pharma, the deep state, election integrity, cannabis freedom, crypto and the money behind all of it.
What is your political stance?
We are pro-liberty, pro-cannabis, anti-war and anti-corruption, and we hold both parties to the same standard. We are not a party outlet. When the people we agree with get something wrong, we say so.
How is Media Mogul funded?
By readers. We take no pharmaceutical advertising and no money from the industries we cover. Support comes from newsletter readers, donations and Media Mogul merchandise.
